The Passion
Aug. 13th, 2003 11:30 amMel Gibson's latest, for those of you who don't follow film news as maniacaally as I do is "The Passion", a teling of Christ's Death told entirely in Latin and Aramaic. The trailer looks fantastically authentic. However there's a fair amount of controversy about it.
So, lacking any precise details about the anti-semitism, I went looking at the New Testament to see what the original sources say. Guess what - all four apostles agree that the guiding force of the crucifixion was the Jewish Priesthood and Mark states categorically (15:11) that the pristehood stirred up the crowd to have Jesus crucified. So unless the complaint is basically that the New Testament is both false and anti-semitic (which the Anti-defamation League doesn't seem to be going for this week) I'm wondering where there complaint lies.
I'm now rather looking forward to this, just to see what happens. Maybe there'll be a double bill with Life of Brian so we can compare and contrast.
Mel Gibson's new movie The Passion has been given the official thumbs down by America's Anti-Defamation League. The controversial film, about the final hours of Jesus Christ's life, was screened for select religious leaders Monday, and Adl officials were far from happy with what they saw. Abraham Foxman, who has been among those heaping criticism on the ambitious project - shot in Italy in the ancient languages of Aramaic and Latin - is convinced the film will infuriate and upset religious people. Foxman says, "We are deeply concerned that the film, if released in its present form, will fuel the hatred, bigotry and anti-Semitism that many responsible churches have worked hard to repudiate." Fellow ADL official Rabbi Eugene Korn, who also saw the movie, adds, "This is not a disagreement between the Jews and Mr. Gibson. Many theologically-informed Catholics and Protestants have expressed the same concerns regarding anti-Semitism and that this film may undermine Christian-Jewish dialogue and could turn back the clock on decades of positive progress in interfaith relations."
So, lacking any precise details about the anti-semitism, I went looking at the New Testament to see what the original sources say. Guess what - all four apostles agree that the guiding force of the crucifixion was the Jewish Priesthood and Mark states categorically (15:11) that the pristehood stirred up the crowd to have Jesus crucified. So unless the complaint is basically that the New Testament is both false and anti-semitic (which the Anti-defamation League doesn't seem to be going for this week) I'm wondering where there complaint lies.
I'm now rather looking forward to this, just to see what happens. Maybe there'll be a double bill with Life of Brian so we can compare and contrast.