andrewducker: (Default)
andrewducker ([personal profile] andrewducker) wrote2017-11-24 12:00 pm

Interesting Links for 24-11-2017

aldabra: (Default)

Re: SF doesn’t really make you stupid. It’s more that if you’re stupid enough to be biased aga

[personal profile] aldabra 2017-11-25 03:27 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes; I love the scope SF gives for warping time and space and consciousness. I think you can do a lot with that which you can't do with litfic, and those are the kinds of ideas I'm interested in. (But I've actively backed off from the space opera and tech-progress porn, because it annoys me too much.)

On the other hand, I'm quite sure that if someone gave me cat detective fiction, or Elizabethan court intrigue fiction, to read I would read it "stupidly", and I'm not convinced that's a bad strategy *even if it's intrinsically as well-written as anything else I read*. Whereas with my current genre of choice, which is deindustrial SF, I probably read it *less* stupidly than it objectively deserves, because those are the settings and counterfactual possibilities I'm most interested in.

I think having genre-preferences is inevitable, under the current proliferation of books such that you can't possibly read everything you might want to even within a genre, and I can see how one might decide sensibly that aliens aren't one's priority. (Though it's harder to see how one decides sensibly that cat detectives are...)
naath: (Default)

Re: SF doesn’t really make you stupid. It’s more that if you’re stupid enough to be biased aga

[personal profile] naath 2017-11-27 09:41 am (UTC)(link)
ebut cats! I think I read most things equally stupidly, I'm not interested in doing litcrit, I just want to have fun.
aldabra: (Default)

Re: SF doesn’t really make you stupid. It’s more that if you’re stupid enough to be biased aga

[personal profile] aldabra 2017-11-27 09:57 am (UTC)(link)
Ha, yes, it was exactly you I was expecting to call me out on dissing cats and Elizabethan court intrigue 8-)

I've read the odd self-published thing which switches genre midway through, in a way which no self-respecting publisher would allow. It certainly wakes you up. (Unfortunately they have a tendency also to misuse punctuation in a way which no self-respecting publisher would allow, and I'm irredeemably twitchy about that.)