Indeed, if absolutely everyone were guilty and the aim of this exercise was purely to try to trick them into confessing something that could be used in a court of law, your reasoning would be perfectly all right :-)
I seem to recall teh version I heard was something like "do you masterbate" or "have you ever been influenced by a source you failed to cite when writing an essay at school" which applies to almost everyone, but isn't illegal.
no subject
no subject