andrewducker: (Tentacular)
andrewducker ([personal profile] andrewducker) wrote2008-07-03 06:40 pm

Somewhere that was leading

There was much amusement this morning when I checked my email and discovered that some people thought that I was trying to do some kind of scientific research via an LJ poll, or thought that I was trying to make a point about how many people had been raped (which was clearly not data you could extract from the question I asked).

Um.

No.

This was all kicked off by the discussion a few days back about the feminism backlash - and specifically by the discussion of how it must be ok to just _say_ things to women - after all, it's just speech, how could it be dangerous?

To which my response was:
You wouldn't make the kind of statement in a rape survivor's group, after all. But the stats seem to show that if you're around more than 4 women then you _are_ in the middle of a rape survivor's group...
("The Stats" and much more can be found here on liberal conspiracy - a site I very much recommend. I don't intend to discuss them further, you can do your own damn reading.)

But anyway - the point is that pretty much everyone knows someone who was raped. Of the nine people currently asserting otherwise on the poll I personally know that three of them are wrong. Someone else commented saying that at least one other one was wrong. I'd like to think that there was at least one person on my friends list who didn't know any sexual assault victims, but I wouldn't care to place money on it. And this raises fear levels - because it makes it much more real than if you didn't know people who are involved. I don't know anyone who's been stabbed (at least I don't think I do), so the stuff in the papers about knife crime kinda bounces off, but sexual assault is much more personal, because it's happened to people I care about deeply.

And it's a crime more likely to be committed by a person you know. With all of the people I know, for instance, about it was friends, or friends of friends. Which leads to mistrust of _all men_. You can't tell from a distance, and so you lost trust that you can open up to anyone.

I was once hanging out with a woman at a convention - we'd met a few times before and got on well, friended each other, exchanged the odd email, etc. And this time, we arrived at the hotel with bags of chips in our hands and needed somewhere to eat them where the staff wouldn't get upset. So I suggested my room. And she gave me an odd look - and it took me a moment to realise that that look was suspicion of my motives. So I reassured her, and we got the lift up. And when we got out she thanked me for not trying to kiss her. Because a _lot_ of men she'd shared lifts with under similar circumstances with had tried something like that. She's in a relationship. She's never shown any interest in me.

And she thanked me. For not trying to kiss her. And I've never been so astounded in my life.

It's insane. It makes me weep for what many women have to go through every sodding day.

I work very hard to make sure people I know feel comfortable around me. I'm naturally huggy and touchy-feely, and it took me a long time to realise that it made some people feel uncomfortable, because I came from a background that _was_ very safe. But eventually I realised that I had to back off. So you won't see me making the first move when it comes to hugging most people, because I do _not_ want to fall into the category of "sleazy man who hugs people to get close to them." And I only have to worry about that because of complete dick's who do that.

There are, if you're lucky, two categories of men in women's head - ones that are safe to be around, and ones that aren't. And you can, if you like, be blunt about sex, and not worry about people's previous experiences, and whether they jump slightly whenever people make any connection between them and sex, and whether they know you well enough to open up to you at all. But you're very likely to be places into category B.

And no, I'm not telling you what to do, or how to speak. Just saying that the world is _not_ a Safe Space, and that we all need to be aware of the consequences of what we say and how we act around people.

[identity profile] seph-hazard.livejournal.com 2008-07-04 08:15 am (UTC)(link)
Actually that's a very good point and I suspect you're right. I think I get so angry about this that I don't think about it properly!
ext_3241: (Default)

[identity profile] pizza.maircrosoft.com (from livejournal.com) 2008-07-04 12:00 pm (UTC)(link)
yeah but there are so many, many people who make off-colour jokes that align them with the obnoxious men to their listeners, even if /they/ know they'd never actually do X, Y, Z. On and on, it's supposed to be *okay* to joke about hiring attractive Brazilian researchers because we know that really we'll be hiring on merit, and people will talk to me about my poster at a conference because they're interested in the subject, honest. And even if they don't, quite, they certainly aren't going to be assualting me in the lifts, are they. Or maybe that was your point.

[identity profile] robhu.livejournal.com 2008-07-04 12:14 pm (UTC)(link)
I do the opposite. When I see a cute girl at something I talk to everyone except her.
ext_3241: (Default)

[identity profile] pizza.maircrosoft.com (from livejournal.com) 2008-07-04 12:35 pm (UTC)(link)
hey, I'm curious - how do you contribute if you're with some colleagues/friends in the pub in the evening and they're joking about the cute girl? Would you just keep quiet?

[identity profile] robhu.livejournal.com 2008-07-04 12:37 pm (UTC)(link)
Is the situation you're suggesting like this:
We have been to a conference where there was a cute girl
Later when she's not around my male (let's assume) friends are making inappropriate jokes about the cute girl.

What do I do?

Is that what you're asking?
ext_3241: (Default)

[identity profile] pizza.maircrosoft.com (from livejournal.com) 2008-07-04 01:12 pm (UTC)(link)
inappropriate is poorly defined.

yeah, that kind of thing. I'm only being nosy.

[identity profile] robhu.livejournal.com 2008-07-04 01:34 pm (UTC)(link)
I might say nothing and be silently annoyed, then annoyed with myself afterwards.

I might speak out at the time and say "Look, that's not funny or appropriate".

I tend towards the latter, but I will shamefully admit I have done the former in the past. It is very costly to stand up against some of the things people say.

If someone was routinely saying really inappropriate things I'd see them far less often.

[identity profile] surliminal.livejournal.com 2008-07-12 09:56 pm (UTC)(link)
This is not just a male issue. (I don't know if that makes you fel better).

I have been in groups (I am often in all-men-but-me groups) where similar not-very-right-on things were said and I have not had the guts or energy to turn on them..

Much of it is also cultural. It's as if groups have different volume controls. I know some Latin American men who make the most non PC comments but in real life (as it were) they are also extremely polite and chivalrous towards most the women i see them actually interacting with. It's just a culture where frankly, it's expected for het men, married or single, to be out to get sex whenever possible and that colours`how they talk about non-present dateable women. (I count as honorary man in these conversations I think because (a) too old to be dateable and (b) mnore senior than them in out context, which is work related.